California voters rejected Proposition 40, a proposed one-time 5% tax on billionaires, according to an Associated Press race call reported on November 10, 2026. The result has prompted competing explanations for why the measure failed despite Democratic gains in the midterm elections.
UC Berkeley economist Gabriel Zucman, a supporter of wealth taxes, attributed the defeat partly to opponents’ spending. Opponents spent almost $400 million fighting Proposition 40, including on competing ballot measures, according to the original report. Zucman said they spent more than $300 million on advertising, while supporters spent comparatively little. In his view, that imbalance gave voters far more exposure to arguments against the tax.
Stanford economist Joshua Rauh, a critic of Proposition 40, questioned whether advertising explains the result. He pointed to progressive Bay Area counties where support for the measure fell well below the support Kamala Harris received in the 2024 presidential election. Rauh argued that voters who live near billionaires or businesses they fund may have been more skeptical of the tax. That is his interpretation of the voting pattern, not an established cause of the defeat.
The measure’s design also drew opposition. It would have directed 90% of projected revenue to health care and the remaining 10% to food assistance and education-related programs. The California Teachers Association opposed it, arguing that it would not provide lasting funding for public schools. Governor Gavin Newsom also opposed the state measure, saying he favored a national approach because wealthy residents could move between states.
Neither economist expects the debate to end with this vote. Zucman anticipated further efforts in Congress; Rauh also expected new proposals but saw little prospect of a federal wealth tax becoming law soon. He raised a constitutional objection to such a tax, though legal scholars disagree on whether the relevant restrictions would apply.